Greatest Rock Singers of All Time Readers Poll, Round 1: James Hetfield (Metallica) Vs. Maynard James Keenan (Tool)

by Guitar World Staff
Posted Oct 8, 2013 at 7:58am

Why should guitarists have all the fun?

GuitarWorld.com recently launched a new readers poll in partnership with Samson: the Greatest Rock Singers of All Time Readers Poll.

We're certain that, even though our core readership is mainly made up of guitarists from different genres, locations and age groups, you — like us — have strong opinions about the skills (or lack thereof) of some of rock's most legendary singers.

And although we had hundreds of rock singers to choose from, we decided to narrow things down to a mere 16 names, all of which were carefully chosen by Guitar World's editorial staff. We took great care in choosing what's essentially a Sweet 16 starting point. Rock singers from every decade, starting with the 1960s, are represented, as are several rock sub-genres.

Here are our 16 rock singers in alphabetical order:

Phil Anselmo, Randy Blythe, Kurt Cobain, Chris Cornell, Bruce Dickinson, Ronnie James Dio, Rob Halford, James Hetfield, Mick Jagger, Maynard James Keenan, Freddie Mercury, Jim Morrison, Ozzy Osbourne, Robert Plant, Axl Rose and Bon Scott.

From there, we drew singers' names out of a hat (It was, in fact, a Black Sabbath baseball cap) to help us create our opening 16-singer bracket, which is available for your viewing pleasure below. Obviously, none of these of singers are ranked or coming from a previously compiled list, so we chose purely random matchups to have as little impact as possible on the final outcome. We're actually pretty pleased with the way the bracket turned out.

Remember that, as with any poll, sub-genre might occasionally clash against sub-genre, so you'll just need to decide which singer has or had the most to offer within his genre and time period, which one has or had more natural talent or technical skill, which one had the biggest influence on other singers or rock in general — maybe which one was simply the stronger frontman.

Let's get started! As always, you can vote only once per matchup (once per device, that is), and we'll post two or three matchups per week, continuing with today's shootout, James Hetfield of Metallica against Maynard James Keenan of Tool, A Perfect Circle and Puscifer.

Latest Results

Winner: Mick Jagger (60.16 percent)
Loser: Axl Rose (39.84 percent)

Today's Samson Greatest Rock Singers Round 1 Matchup (6 of 8)
James Hetfield Vs. Maynard James Keenan

james125.jpgJAMES HETFIELD

Born: August 3, 1963, Downey, California
Associated Acts: Metallica
Website: metallica.com

Quote: "I'd much rather talk about guitar playing. I hate it when people ask me about my lyrics. I always feel like telling them to just go and read them."



tool125.jpgMAYNARD JAMES KEENAN

Born: April 17, 1964, Ravenna, Ohio
Associated Acts: Tool, A Perfect Circle, Puscifer, Green Jellÿ
Website: toolband.com

Quote: "I just hope that our fans are people who are inspired by music, and just use our music as a background or inspiration for whatever it is they do."

Vote Now!

Samson Greatest Rock Singers of All Time Readers Poll, Round 1: James Hetfield Vs. Maynard James Keenan

Thanks for voting! Check out our current matchup (and every matchup that has taken place so far) right HERE.

The Bracket

Check out the latest version of the 16-singer bracket below. We'll update it after each Samson Greatest Rock Singer of All Time matchup.

October 8, 2013, Samson Greatest Rock Singers of All Time Readers Poll


Add a Comment
0 Comments

Similar Guitar News

Jason Newsted Discusses His Metallica Audition — Video (11/30/2015)
In this new extract from That Metal Show, which was posted to YouTube by VH1 November 30, bassist Jason Newsted discusses his Metallica audition and the death of Cliff Burton. Newsted joined Metallica in 1986 after Burton's death and remained a ...
Chris Cornell Performs "One" with U2's Music and Metallica's Lyrics — Video (11/30/2015)
Right off the bat, this one is not new. In fact, it's from 2013. Still, we like it—and you might too! It's a fan-shot clip of Chris Cornell performing "One." Songs titled "One" were huge for U2 and Metallica, even though their respective "One" c...
Watch Metallica's James Hetfield "Audition" for ‘Call of Duty’ — Video (8/28/2015)
As part of the Call of Duty: Black Ops III charity campaign to help military veterans find employment after their service, the charity group Omaze has released a new video showing celebrities “auditioning’ to play the role of a zombie in the vid...
Watch Metallica's Full Rock in Rio USA Set — Video (5/11/2015)
Over the weekend, Metallica headlined Rock in Rio USA, a rock festival that took over the Las Vegas Strip. Metallica's two-hour set was streamed around the world via Yahoo! Live, and you can check it out below (in case you happened to miss it). ...
Watch Metallica's "Nothing Else Matters" Played from the Inside of a Guitar — Video (7/23/2015)
Below, check out a recently posted (July 18) video of a guy who puts his camera inside his acoustic guitar and plays Metallica’s "Nothing Else Matters." Like similar videos that show the brilliant shapes, oscillations and motions of strings that...
Watch a Banjo Cover of Metallica’s “Battery” — Video (5/13/2015)
Here we have the latest clever offering from YouTube sensation Rob Scallon, a banjo-riffic cover of Metallica’s “Battery.” It’s part of what Scallon is calling Maytallica, a month long celebration that we’re happy to endorse. Below, enjoy a cou...
Tool Tease January 2016 U.S. Tour Dates (11/17/2015)
It seems as though Tool are one step away from officially announcing their 2016 tour dates. A mere two weeks after playing their only show of 2015, Tool posted the following message on their Facebook page last night. It alludes to several U.S. t...
Tool Perform New Song, "Descending" — Video (11/3/2015)
As we reported yesterday, Tool performed their only show of 2015 on Halloween and dressed up as Led Zeppelin for the occasion. The group also opened with their cover of Zeppelin’s “No Quarter,” which they have not performed live since 1998. Aud...
Tool Dress Up As Led Zeppelin and Perform "No Quarter" — Video (11/2/2015)
Over the weekend, in fact on Halloween, Tool dressed up as Led Zeppelin and performed “No Quarter” at the Monster Mash Music Festival in Tempe, Arizona. “Good news—it’s f–ing Halloween!” Maynard James Keenan reportedly said after the performanc...
This All-Ukulele Cover of Metallica's "One" Is Simply Incredible — Video (8/24/2015)
Below, check out an all-ukulele cover of Metallica's "One." It's performed by a guy who calls his project "Ukes of Hazzard," which is a pretty cool name, if you ask us. "This was by far the most difficult cover I've done," he says on YouTube. "I...
Smooth Jazz Version of Metallica's "Enter Sandman" — Video (7/2/2015)
Today we bring you a very well-done smooth jazz version of Metallica's "Enter Sandman." The video, which was created and posted a few Februarys ago, is the handiwork of YouTube user Andy Rehfeldt, who adds: "All instruments were arranged, played...
San Francisco Giants Metallica Day 2015: National Anthem and Behind-the-Scenes Interview — Video (5/14/2015)
Earlier this month, the San Francisco Giants hosted their third-annual Metallica Day at their home base, AT&T Park. Drummer Lars Ulrich threw out the first pitch, while guitarists James Hetfield and Kirk Hammett performed "The Star Spangled...
Readers' Poll: The Best American Rock Band Ever — Metallica Vs. Nirvana (9/28/2015)
When Labor Day came and went earlier this month, it reminded us of the American labor movement and the contributions American workers have made to the strength, prosperity and well-being of the good ol' U.S. of A. However, since we're Guitar Wor...
Readers' Poll: The Best American Rock Band Ever — Foo Fighters Vs. Metallica (9/14/2015)
When Labor Day came and went earlier this month, it reminded us of the American labor movement and the contributions American workers have made to the strength, prosperity and well-being of the good ol' U.S. of A. However, since we're Guitar Wor...
Readers' Poll: Best Rock Headphone Song Ever — "Bohemian Rhapsody" (Queen) Vs. “Eulogy” (Tool) (10/28/2015)
What, exactly, is a headphone song? The definition changes depending on who you are. For audiophiles, a headphone song—or album, for that matter—is a work that is so exquisite that it demands you listen to each beautifully recorded note under a ...
More Open-String Lick Ideas from Metallica's Kirk Hammett (10/13/2015)
This classic "The Sound and The Fury" column by Metallica's Kirk Hammett is from the July 2000 issue of Guitar World magazine. Last month, we took a class look at the opening four bars of my solo in "Of Wolf and Man" (Metallica). As you may rem...