Album Review: Bob Dylan — 'Another Self Portrait (1969-1971), The Bootleg Series Vol. 10'

by Jeff Slate
Posted Sep 2, 2013 at 3:48pm

The thing about being a fan of Bob Dylan is that the discovery of his greatness is never-ending.

In preparing to review the great new 10th volume of his Bootleg Series, Another Self Portrait (1969-1971), I was distracted by a host of bootlegs that have been sitting on my hard drive, unlistened to for ages.

After spending a few days with Another Self Portrait, my Dylan jones seriously piqued, I rooted around and found a spectacular soundboard of Dylan with the Band from Madison Square Garden in 1974.

Then I dove into a fan-compiled bootleg of songs from Modern Times from his 2007 European tour, outtakes from Pat Garrett and Billy The Kid and sessions with Carl Perkins, Johnny Cash, Marshall Grant and WS Holland from 1969, and George Harrison, Charlie Daniels, Billy Mundi and Bob Johnson from 1970.

Thoroughly engrossed and completely distracted by the task at hand, I got back to Another Self Portrait. Much has been made about how great this release is and how it eclipses Dylan’s 1970 album, Self Portrait, by a long stretch. Both are true, but that has been true about much of Dylan’s Bootleg Series.

Live 1975: The Rolling Thunder Revue was arguably a more consistent and engaging portrait of Dylan in that period. And Tell Tale Signs: Rare and Unreleased 1989–2006 was a stunning trip through later-period Dylan, particularly highlighting the strength of his oft-overlooked pre-Time Out Of Mind output. Perhaps even moments of — let the heresy commence — Live 1964: Concert at Philharmonic Hall and Live 1966: The Royal Albert Hall best Dylan’s revered studio work of those same periods.

Or do they? The reality is that all of these releases have forced us to revisit and reassess various periods of Dylan’s career and what we — as reviewers or simply fans — have discovered is that he has always been great; we just might not have noticed at the time.

Many reviews of Another Self Portrait, in making the argument that it is significantly stronger than Self Portrait, have noted that much of what Dylan recorded and moved on from but didn’t release circa 1970 were essentially masterpieces unloved or under-appreciated by their creator.

I went back and listened to Self Portrait, something I hadn’t done in a long time. It’s great. It’s more finished and of its time than its Bootleg Series counterpart, but the thing that struck me in reflecting on this entry in the series and the nine volumes that came before it — not to mention Dylan’s official studio output — was the consistency of Dylan’s output. It’s all great. Seriously.

To those who quibble about his ragged voice or “weird” delivery or reinventing his classics or “that” Christmas album or the idiosyncratic nature of his muse, look no further than Mumford & Sons or Dawes or Fleet Foxes or Jack White — or the plethora of bearded banjo players or pixies in hoop skirts that populate YouTube and Facebook — to see that just about every aspect of Dylan’s career is represented in what we music lovers like to think of as “real” music.

So what does Another Self Portrait show us? That Dylan was there first, he did it better, and we’re just playing catch up.

I could tell you about all the cool moments or outstanding tracks on Another Self Portrait, but if you’re a fan, you’ve already poured over the many hand-wringing reviews that have been all over the Internet in the past weeks. Dylan sounds great, the songs and performances are peerless, and though stylistically Another Self Portrait is a bit all over the place (owing mostly to the fact that the sessions the material is culled from spans three years) it also is remarkably coherent.

The guitar work — whether acoustic strumming or flat-picking, punchy electric lines and pedal steel — is stellar and, most of all, tasteful throughout. In essence, Another Self Portrait is a five-star album any music lover should have in his or her collection. It’s great music, played by a true master that you’ll enjoy over and over. And you might just learn something and gain some perspective on Dylan and music in general in the process.

Now that’s saying something.

Jeff Slate is a NYC-based solo singer-songwriter and music journalist. He founded and fronted the band the Badge for 15 years beginning in 1997 and has worked with Pete Townshend, Earl Slick, Carlos Alomar, Steve Holley, Laurence Juber and countless others. He has interviewed and written about everyone from the Beatles and Kiss to Monty Python and rock musicals on Broadway. He is an avid collector of rock and roll books and bootlegs and has an encyclopedic knowledge of all things Dylan and the Beatles. For more information, visit jeffslate.net.


Add a Comment
0 Comments

Similar Guitar News

The Doors' Robby Krieger Discusses Bob Dylan's 'Bringing It All Back Home' — The Record That Changed My Life (8/1/2014)
Robby Krieger of the Doors chooses and discusses the record that changed his life. Bob DylanBringing It All Back Home (1965) “This guy from Marblehead, Massachusetts, who I knew in school named Bill Phinity turned me onto Bob Dylan. "We had a j...
Charlie Daniels to Release Bob Dylan Tribute Album April 1st (3/28/2014)
Charlie Daniels, best known for his No. 1 country hit "The Devil Went Down to Georgia," is set to release a new album, Off The Grid - Doin’ It Dylan. As his tribute to Bob Dylan, the new record gives 77-year-old Daniels the opportunity to pay re...
Elvis Costello, Marcus Mumford, Jim James and More Write Music for Long-Lost Bob Dylan Lyrics (3/25/2014)
Recording is nearly complete for Lost On The River: The New Basement Tapes. The project features Elvis Costello, Rhiannon Giddens (Carolina Chocolate Drops), Taylor Goldsmith (Dawes), Jim James (My Morning Jacket), Marcus Mumford (Mumford &...
'Bob Dylan In The '80s: Volume One' to be Released March 25 (3/7/2014)
Bob Dylan In The 80s: Volume One will be released on March 25. The brainchild of producers Jesse Lauter (Elvis Perkins, The Low Anthem) and Sean O'Brien (Dawes, PAPA), the mission of Bob Dylan In The 80s: Volume One is to shed new light on a la...
Highlights of Bob Dylan’s ‘Bootleg Series’ (12/31/2013)
Standing as probably the greatest American songwriter of all time, the musical catalog of Bob Dylan is nothing short of awe-inspiring. 35 studio albums, 11 live albums, and innumerable compilations contain countless brilliant moments from the al...
Bob Dylan's Newport Strat sells for $965,000 (12/9/2013)
Read more about Bob Dylan's Newport Strat sells for $965,000 at MusicRadar.com The historic '64 Fender Stratocaster used by Bob Dylan at the 1965 Newport Folk Festival has been sold for a record breaking sum at auction.The sunburst Strat took ce...
Bob Dylan's Famous Newport Folk Festival Strat Sells for Nearly $1 Million (12/7/2013)
This past Friday, December 6, a Fender Strat that once belonged to Bob Dylan sold for $965,000 at Christie's in New York City, setting a new world auction record for any guitar (not including private sales), according to a statement from the auc...
Bob Dylan on Critics: "All Those Evil Motherf---ers Can Rot in Hell" (9/12/2012)
With yesterday's release of Tempest, perhaps his darkest effort to date, Bob Dylan has shown that he's still got plenty of fire left in him. And some of that fire is being directed at critics. Dylan is featured on the latest cover of the new iss...
Bob Dylan's New Album, 'Tempest' Streaming Now at iTunes (9/7/2012)
As we’ve reported, Bob Dylan’s 35th studio album, Tempest, will be released September 11. For those of you who can’t wait till Tuesday to hear what Rolling Stone considers a five-star album, head to iTunes, where the entire release is streaming ...
Full Story of Bob Dylan and The Band Coming to DVD (8/16/2012)
In 1966 Bob Dylan began his first electric world tour. It was a landmark moment for Dylan and the history of rock music, and it bitterly divided his audience. Backing Dylan on stage was an obscure group of Canadian musicians collectively known a...
Hear Bob Dylan's "Early Roman Kings" from New Album, 'Tempest' (8/2/2012)
Bob Dylan's 35th studio album, Tempest, will be released September 11. And while that's still more than a month away, Dylan fans can hear one of the songs off the new album, "Early Roman Kings," in the trailer for Season 2 of Cinemax's series St...
Bob Dylan's 35th Studio Album, 'Tempest,' Expected September 11 (7/17/2012)
Bob Dylan will release his 35th studio album -- Tempest -- September 11 on Columbia Records. Fifty years ago, Dylan released his self-titled debut, also on Columbia. It mostly flew under the radar and didn't sell particularly well. But after 1...
The Making of Dylan's "Love and Theft" (9/27/2001)
Two weeks, twelve songs - that's all it took for a new classic
New Dead Tribute to Feature Costello, Dylan (6/1/2000)
Elvis Costello, Bob Dylan among those on Grateful Dead project
Bob Dylan, Phil Lesh to Tour Together (5/29/2000)
Summer tour to feature Dylan, Dead bassist