Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time, The Finals — Eddie Van Halen Vs. Brian May

by Guitar World Staff
Posted Oct 8, 2012 at 12:00pm

Welcome to the Finals of our first-ever Greatest Guitarist poll!

It all started a few months back, when 128 132 guitarists went head to head, round by round, in a bracketed format. We filled all but four of the slots with the names of incredible guitarists (dead and living) — players chosen for their technical ability as well as their importance and creativity, not to mention how influential they've been. We asked our readers to vote in the final four names, which you did, selecting Nuno Bettencourt, Chet Atkins, Malcolm Young and Jake E. Lee.

But now, several rounds later, we're into the final matchup, which is being brought to you by Sweetwater Sound.

Some things to take to consider before casting your vote:

Influence: Who inspired more kids to beg their parents for a guitar for Christmas? Who inspired a wave of copycats?
Chops/Versatility: Is the guitarist in question a one-trick pony or a master of many styles?
Body of Work: Who had the more consistent career? Who has played on more classic albums?
Creativity: Who pioneered new techniques? Who sounds the most radically different from what came before them?

You can check out the full results via our regularly updated bracket here and at the bottom of this story. (Click on the bracket to expand it.)

The Finals

EDDIE VAN HALEN may have earned the moniker "King Edward" from his virtuoso guitar chops, but he's just one match away from being crowned your choice for the greatest of all time. Slash, Randy Rhoads, Joe Satriani and Alex Lifeson have all fallen in his wake, with only one more guitarist needing to bite the dust for his reign at the top to commence.

With the Queen Army behind him, who can stop BRIAN MAY? Dr. May has beaten a path to the finals through a thicket of some of the biggest names in guitar, including Jeff Beck, George Harrison, Les Paul, Jimmy Page and Jimi Hendrix, proving that it's hard to beat a vibrant and dedicated fan base. May looks to play the part of the People's Champion if he can rock the cradle one more time today and walk away the winner.

Readers Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time — Van Halen Vs. May

Guitar World Staff Picks

JIMMY BROWN, Senior Music Editor

Pick: Brian May

This is a tough choice, as both guitarists did so much for advancing the art of rock guitar and breaking new ground, in terms of playing techniques, tones, riff writing and recording. I would have to choose May, due to the simple fact that he came first and did what he did without the benefit of the wonderful example of, well, Brian May.


JOSH HART, Online Producer

Pick: Eddie Van Halen

Ed was revolutionary on too many fronts to pick against him. Brian May is a tremendous guitarist, an excellent songwriter and has my eternal respect as a both a musician and astrophysicist, but I feel his ride should end here.


PAUL RIARIO, Technical Editor

Pick: Eddie Van Halen

Pop quiz: You're halfway through the finale of Gossip Girl and the annoying guitarist in your band asks, "Brian May or Eddie Van Halen?" Do you answer (A) "Can we wait till the commercial?" or "Is this really important?" (B) Brian May, because he built (with his dad) his first guitar that he used throughout his career out of a fireplace and most of his band's songs can be heard during sporting events and Simon Cowell shows, or (C) "Wait a minute, Jimmy Page and Jimi Hendrix are not an option?" Actually, the answer is (D) Eddie Van Halen. Because ... I know, without his influence in just about everything guitar-related, I wouldn't have a job.


DAMIAN FANELLI, Online Managing Editor

Pick: Eddie Van Halen

Friends and co-workers are starting to think I don't like Brian May because I keep picking against him. That's not the case at all. I have ridiculous amounts of respect for his playing and for the iconic stature of his band and the many, many impressive recordings they made back in the day. That being said, I, um, need to pick against him once again. I'll just cut and paste my paragraph from the Hendrix-Vs.-May contest, since my argument is essentially the same (I've replaced Hendrix's name with Van Halen's): "Brian May, certainly a very logical, intelligent, gifted human, would — obviously — pick Eddie Van Halen. As do I."


TOM BEAUJOUR: Editor-In-Chief, Guitar Aficionado

Pick: Eddie Van Halen

I am a 41-year-old man who, two days ago at a dinner party, spent 10 minutes explaining to a fellow guest that Eddie Van Halen is the most naturally free and and gifted guitarist in the history of rock music. I love Brian May too, but I can't say that I've ever embarrassed myself over aperitifs and hors d'oeuvres by singing his praises.


Add a Comment

Similar Guitar News

Watch One of the 'Minions' Play Van Halen's "Eruption" — Video (7/10/2015)
As you might've detected from the non-stop (and fairly annoying) TV commercials, Minions opened in theaters today. The animated comedy, which is about gibberish-spewing yellow creatures who are looking for someone to serve, happens to feature a ...
Watch Eddie Van Halen Shred at Van Halen’s Hollywood Bowl Tour Finale — Video (10/5/2015)
Last night marked the end of Van Halen’s 2015 North American tour, and the band made sure it was a night to remember. They took the stage at the Hollywood Bowl for two nights, October 2 and 4, returning to Los Angeles, where they kicked off the ...
Watch Eddie Van Halen Play Jimi Hendrix, Led Zeppelin and The Beatles — Video (7/9/2015)
Bassist Billy Sheehan recently appeared on Eddie Trunk’s podcast, where he revealed that Van Halen had twice invited him to join the group to replace Michael Anthony. Sheehan also noted in that interview that he has played with all the members ...
Van Halen Perform "Panama" at Billboard Music Awards — Video (5/18/2015)
Last night, Van Halen kicked off the Billboard Music Awards with a powerful performance of "Panama," which you can check out below. David Lee Roth turned in a solid vocal performance that was a step up from Van Halen's recent appearances on Jimm...
Thirty Guitar Legends — Including Eddie Van Halen, Dimebag Darrell and Jeff Beck — Pick the Song They'd Most Want to Be Remembered By, Part 1 (6/24/2015)
From the GW Archive: This feature originally appeared in the May 2002 issue of Guitar World. The story has a "time capsule" theme: We asked several veteran guitarists to choose the one song they'd most want to be remembered by after many years. ...
Sammy Hagar Responds to Eddie Van Halen's Billboard Interview: "F— You, You’re a Liar!” — Video (6/22/2015)
Over the weekend, singer Sammy Hagar responded to several claims made by Eddie Van Halen in a high-profile new Billboard interview. Hagar was particularly upset about Van Halen’s statements concerning former Van Halen bassist Michael Anthony. I...
Roth Erupts and Van Halen Stop Show When Fan Throws Beer Onstage — Video [NSFW] (8/31/2015)
David Lee Roth had some choice words for a fan who threw a beer onstage at Van Halen’s August 27 performance in Camden, New Jersey. The group were just launching into “Dirty Movies” at the Susquehanna Bank Center when Roth stopped the show. “So...
Rosie Botterill Covers Joe Satriani's "Satch Boogie" and Eddie Van Halen's "Beat It" Guitar Solo — Video (10/20/2015)
Here's something we found on a growing Facebook community called Shreddelicious: Female Guitar Players Community. It's a new cover (October 16) of Joe Satriani's "Satch Boogie" by guitarist Rosie Botterill. The track is from Satch’s landmark Sur...
Ritchie Blackmore, David Gilmour, Brian May and Others Play "Smoke on the Water" in 1989 — Video (7/13/2015)
It was 26 years ago this week that one of the greatest guitar hero gatherings of all time got under way. The occasion was a remake of the 1972 Deep Purple hit “Smoke on the Water” that featured some of the biggest players in rock, including Ritc...
Readers' Poll: The Best American Rock Band Ever — Van Halen Vs. Red Hot Chili Peppers (9/9/2015)
When Labor Day came and went earlier this month, it reminded us of the American labor movement and the contributions American workers have made to the strength, prosperity and well-being of the good ol' U.S. of A. However, since we're Guitar Wor...
Readers' Poll: The Best American Rock Band Ever — Van Halen Vs. Bruce Springsteen and The E Street Band (9/30/2015)
When Labor Day came and went earlier this month, it reminded us of the American labor movement and the contributions American workers have made to the strength, prosperity and well-being of the good ol' U.S. of A. However, since we're Guitar Wor...
Readers' Poll: Best Rock Headphone Song Ever — "Tomorrow Never Knows" (The Beatles) Vs. "Girl Gone Bad" (Van Halen) (11/3/2015)
What, exactly, is a headphone song? The definition changes depending on who you are. For audiophiles, a headphone song—or album, for that matter—is a work that is so exquisite that it demands you listen to each beautifully recorded note under a ...
Queen's Brian May: ‘Wayne’s World’ “Bohemian Rhapsody” Scene Hit Close to Home (11/2/2015)
Saturday, October 31, marked exactly 40 years since Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody” was released. Despite four decades of performing and hearing the song, guitarist Brian May still enjoys what is undoubtedly his biggest hit. “I’m not sick of it,” he...
Queen's Brian May Provides "Rude Awakenings" on New Kalinich and Tiven Album (7/1/2015)
Today, GuitarWorld.com presents "Rude Awakenings," a new song by Kalinich and Tiven that features a somewhat unorthodox guitar solo by Queen's Brian May. The track is from Kalinich and Tiven's new album, Each Soul Has a Voice, which will be rele...
Paul Gilbert Performs Van Halen's "Spanish Fly" — Video (6/29/2015)
Below, check out a video of Racer X/Mr. Big guitarist Paul Gilbert playing "Spanish Fly," a classic 1979 instrumental tune by Van Halen. Although we're not sure when (or where) the brief clip was filmed, we do know it was posted to YouTube early...