Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time, Round 4 — David Gilmour Vs. Jimi Hendrix

by Guitar World Staff
Posted Sep 17, 2012 at 10:10am

Welcome to the Sweet 16 portion of our first-ever Greatest Guitarist poll!

It all started a few months back, when 128 132 guitarists went head to head, round by round, in a bracketed format. We filled all but four of the slots with the names of incredible guitarists (dead and living) — players chosen for their technical ability as well as their importance and creativity, not to mention how influential they've been. We asked our readers to vote in the final four names, which you did, selecting Nuno Bettencourt, Chet Atkins, Malcolm Young and Jake E. Lee.

But now, several rounds later, we're into the Sweet 16, which is being brought to you by Sweetwater Sound.

Some things to take to consider before casting your vote:

Influence: Who inspired more kids to beg their parents for a guitar for Christmas? Who inspired a wave of copycats?
Chops/Versatility: Is the guitarist in question a one-trick pony or a master of many styles?
Body of Work: Who had the more consistent career? Who has played on more classic albums?
Creativity: Who pioneered new techniques? Who sounds the most radically different from what came before them?

You can check out the full results via our regularly updated bracket here and at the bottom of this story. (Click on the bracket to expand it.)

Round 4 — Today's Match

There have been a lot of close matchups in the first three rounds of the tournament, but JIMI HENDRIX hasn't been involved in any of them. The 15-time Guitar World cover star has yet to pull less than 75 percent of the vote in any of his matchups, most recently thwarting a hot Billy Gibbons, who was fresh off a big win over Joe Walsh.

For tasteful guitar playing, there is perhaps no one more name checked by his fellow musicians than DAVID GILMOUR. The Pink Floyd guitarist may not be the fastest guy on the planet, but he has become the go-to example of what a guitar player in a band setting should be, With wins over Keith Richards and Angus Young already, don't take Gilmour lightly, even if he is up against Jimi Hendrix.

Readers Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time — Hendrix Vs. Gilmour

Guitar World Staff Picks

JIMMY BROWN, Senior Music Editor

Pick: Jimi Hendrix

Gilmour's celebrated, enduring body of work epitomizes the ideal of polished, hi-fi guitar playing. One of my biggest heroes for sure. But Hendrix was a visionary crusader who revolutionized the role of his instrument and established a new paradigm called rock guitar. His rhythm playing also rules.

------------------

JOSH HART, Online Producer

Pick: David Gilmour

"David Gilmour can say more in one note than ______ can say in 100!" How many times have you heard that argument made in one of those feeling-versus-speed debates that always seem to arise among guitarists? And rightly so. Gilmour is the epitome of tasteful, emotional guitar playing and, in my opinion, a more refined guitarist than Jimi Hendrix. There's no denying Hendrix's massive influence; the fact is we simply didn't get to see enough of him to know how he would evolve as an artist given, say, another 10 years. I hate to handicap him for that, but seeing Gilmour evolve as a guitarist from A Saucerful of Secrets to a song like "Dogs" demonstrates exactly the kind of career arc I would expect from a great guitarist.

------------------

DAMIAN FANELLI, Online Managing Editor

Pick: Jimi Hendrix

I love David Gilmour. After all, who can forget his immortal guitar solo on Paul McCartney's "No More Lonely Nights" in 1984? (I'm kidding!) But seriously, as gifted a guitarist as Gilmour is, he's come up against the wrong opponent, hasn't he? To me, this is a bit like last Friday's poll, which pitted Brian May against Les Paul. Then, as now, we see a great guitarist going up against a revolutionary, game-changing guitarist whose name conjures thoughts of boundless inspiration and innovation. Simply put, the game changer (Hendrix) deserves to win.

------------------

PAUL RIARIO, Technical Editor

Pick: Jimi Hendrix

There are a select few who appear out of nowhere and change the rules of the game; Hendrix is one of those guys. The guitar had been a mere accompaniment instrument prior to his arrival, and through his cocksure showmanship and blazing fretwork, the term "lead guitarist" was born. Jimi was a conduit and his Stratocaster a channel to transmit otherworldly sounds from his head and body. A visionary musician and songwriter, and even now — 42 years after his death — his guitar playing still resonates with anyone willing to grapple with six strings.

------------------

TOM BEAUJOUR, Editor-In-Chief, Guitar Aficionado

Pick: Jimi Hendrix

Hendrix was an icon and a visionary who toppled barriers, both racial and musical. He changed how players and non-players approach the instrument, and if they ever replace the faces on Mount Rushmore, his will be up there as one of the four; the other three would be could the topic of another Internet rumble. That said, his career was brief, and a short three years into it, there was already evidence that he had said everything he had to, compositionally and musically. Gilmour, on the other hand, has never seemed at loss for a voice and has proven to be a long-distance runner and a maker of music (not just guitar music) that has moved millions across generations. But Hendrix, he ain't ... not that he would want him to be.

Sweet16Bracket.jpg


Add a Comment
0 Comments

Similar Guitar News

Hear Jimi Hendrix's Final Interview from September 11, 1970 (5/15/2013)
On September 11, 1970, NME’s Keith Allston interviewed Jimi Hendrix in England. The interview turned out to be Hendrix's last; he died a mere seven days later at age 27. You can hear the entire 30-plus-minute interview below. It's well known tha...
1969 Telegram from Jimi Hendrix and Miles Davis: Can Paul McCartney Come Out to Play? (5/11/2013)
It's well known that Jimi Hendrix was looking to branch out and make some major stylistic changes not long before his death in September 1970. It's also well known that Hendrix and trumpet master Miles Davis were making plans to work together i...
The 10 Best Covers of Jimi Hendrix Songs (5/1/2013)
When someone is widely hailed as the greatest guitar player ever, how do you step up and cover one of his songs? Have you ever noticed that the ratio of Metallica tribute albums to Hendrix tribute albums is something like 20 to 1? When's the las...
Interview: Bassist Billy Sheehan Talks Jimi Hendrix, Steve Vai and New NIACIN Album, 'Krush' (4/1/2013)
From his early days with Talas and David Lee Roth to his time spent with Mr. Big and Steve Vai, bassist Billy Sheehan has performed and recorded with some gigantic names in rock. But no other outlet allows Sheehan to flex his bass muscle quite l...
Gayageum-Style Video: Girl Covers Jimi Hendrix, Stevie Ray Vaughan on Traditional Korean Instrument (3/28/2013)
Check out these videos of a young woman — Luna Lee — performing iconic tracks by Jimi Hendrix and Stevie Ray Vaughan on the gayageum, a traditional Korean zither-like instrument. The gayageum has 12 strings, although some variants have been mad...
Dear Guitar Hero: Jeff Beck Talks Jimi Hendrix, the British Blues Explosion and His "Poor Man’s Pedal Steel" Approach (3/27/2013)
He is held in the highest regard by Eric Clapton and Jimmy Page, was close friends with Jimi Hendrix, and his mid-Sixties recordings with the Yardbirds invented the sound for heavy metal guitar. But what Guitar World readers really want to know ...
Was Jimi Hendrix Out of Control During His Final Days in the Studio? Evidence Emerges on 'People, Hell and Angels' (3/12/2013)
This is an excerpt from the April 2013 issue of Guitar World magazine. For the rest of this story, plus two other Jimi Hendrix features and the tab for "Dolly Dagger," check out the issue at the Guitar World Online Store. Was Jimi Hendrix spinn...
In Deep with Andy Aledort: Jimi Hendrix — "Freedom" (3/8/2013)
This video is bonus content related to the March 2011 issue of Guitar World magazine. For full print reviews, lesson tabs and more, see the March 2011 issue of Guitar World. (It's the one with the 100 Greatest Metallica Songs on the cover. If y...
100 Greatest Guitar Solos, No. 4: Pink Floyd — "Comfortably Numb" (David Gilmour) (3/6/2013)
How do you reason with two guys who once went to court over the artistic ownership of a big rubber pig? That was Bob Ezrin’s mission when he agreed to co-produce Pink Floyd’s The Wall with guitarist David Gilmour and bassist/vocalist Roger Wate...
Jimi Hendrix producer Eddie Kramer talks People, Hell & Angels (3/5/2013)
Read more about Jimi Hendrix producer Eddie Kramer talks People, Hell & Angels at MusicRadar.com
Listen: Jimi Hendrix — Unreleased Version of "Hear My Train a-Comin'" from 'People, Hell and Angels' (2/21/2013)
As most Jimi Hendrix fans know by now, Experience Hendrix and Legacy will release a new Hendrix album, People, Hell and Angels, on March 5. The album features several previously unheard Hendrix recordings tracked between 1968 and 1970. The song...
In Deep: The Jimi Hendrix Rhythm Guitar Method (2/20/2013)
These videos are bonus content related to the December 2011 issue of Guitar World. For full print reviews, lesson tabs and more, look for the December 2011 issue of Guitar World on newsstands now, or purchase this issue in our online store here....
Unreleased 1968 Jimi Hendrix Track, "Somewhere," Streaming Online (1/9/2013)
In a video posted back in November, a clip of a "new" Hendrix track called "Somewhere" could be heard as engineer Eddie Kramer discussed the making of People, Hell & Angels, a collection of twelve previously unreleased studio recordings from...
Jimi Hendrix's People, Hell And Angels track-by-track (1/6/2013)
Read more about Jimi Hendrix's People, Hell And Angels track-by-track at MusicRadar.com On
Jimi Hendrix Collector's Pack available for pre-order now (1/4/2013)
Read more about Jimi Hendrix Collector's Pack available for pre-order now at MusicRadar.com Fancy getting your hands on some previously unreleased Jimi Hendrix? Then Classic Rock's latest Collector's Pack, which hits shops on 4 March 2013 and is...
IK Multimedia’s AmpliTube Jimi Hendrix Now Available On The App Store (12/21/2012)
Sunrise, FL (December 21, 2012) – IK Multimedia, in collaboration with Authentic Hendrix, LLC, is proud to announce the release of AmpliTube Jimi Hendrix for iPhone/iPod touch, and AmpliTube Jimi Hendrix for iPad, the first multi-FX modeling app...