Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time, Round 2 — Eric Johnson Vs. Paul Gilbert

by Guitar World Staff
Posted Jul 9, 2012 at 10:09am

Welcome to our first-ever Greatest Guitarist poll, where 128 guitarists go head to head, round by round, in a bracketed format, all to crown your choice for the Greatest Guitarist of All Time.

We filled 124 of 128 slots with the names of a host of incredible guitarists (dead and living) — players chosen for their technical ability as well as their importance and creativity, not to mention how influential they've been. We asked you to vote in the final four names, which you did. Now the 128 slots are filled, and we're already well into Round 2.

You might come across one or two interesting style matchups in this poll, which may lead some of you to wonder, "How do you compare a shred guitarist to a blues guitarist?" Aside from how good a player is at his or her given style, here are some things to take into consideration:

Influence: Who inspired more kids to beg their parents for a guitar for Christmas? Who inspired a wave of copycats?
Chops/Versatility: Is the guitarist in question a one-trick pony or a master of many styles?
Body of Work: Who had the more consistent career? Who has played on more classic albums?
Creativity: Who pioneered new techniques? Who sounds the most radically different from what came before them?

You can check out full results via our regularly updated bracket here.

Round 2 — Today's Match

Things are really heating up in Round 2 of our poll to determine your pick for the greatest guitarist of all time. Several heavy favorites have been eliminated early, and now two more square off in today's matchup. Will Paul Gilbert or Eric Johnson survive and move on to Round 3? Vote now!

And for more on the world's fastest guitarists, check out our look at the 50 Fastest Guitarists of All Time.

Readers Poll: The Greatest Guitarist of All Time — Johnson Vs. Gilbert

Friday's matchup saw George Harrison (74.95%) defeat Rick Nielsen (25.05%). View the full bracket.


Add a Comment
0 Comments

Similar Guitar News

Essential Listening: Eric Johnson's 10 Greatest Guitar Songs (4/14/2015)
As much as he might try to deny it, Eric Johnson is a member of that small group of players sometimes referred to as "guitarists' guitarists." Players—like Jeff Beck, for instance—whose skills are (secretly, perhaps) the envy of his peers. John...
Paul Gilbert Demos His Signature Ibanez FRM150 Guitar — Video (4/8/2015)
In this video, which was posted by Ibanez earlier this year, Paul Gilbert demos his latest signature guitar, the Ibanez FRM150. "When I pick up my Ibanez Fireman, I know that everything is going to be all right," says the Mr. Big guitarist. "I...
Eric Johnson Picking Lesson: Rolling Threes ("Cascade," Chapter 12) — Video (4/1/2015)
Today we bring you the latest lesson video by Troy Grady, the guitarist who brings you those ultra-intriguing "Cracking the Code" lesson videos that appear on GuitarWorld.com. "This is 'Cascade,' a chapter from our latest Masters in Mechanics se...
NAMM 2015: Roland announces the Eric Johnson Blues Cube Tone Capsule (1/23/2015)
Read more about NAMM 2015: Roland announces the Eric Johnson Blues Cube Tone Capsule at MusicRadar.com NAMM 2015: Eric Johnson's complete mastery of tone and taste has made him one of the most influential guitarists in history. Debuting at Winte...
Cracking the Code with Troy Grady: Eric Johnson's Pickslanting Pentatonics (1/15/2015)
The cascading waterfall of sound that is Eric Johnson's lead playing has captivated players and listeners for 30 years. Sonically, it's an almost formless wash of sunshine. In Johnson's ethereal soundscape, all the edges are smoothed away. Ev...
Paul Gilbert and Billy Sheehan Discuss Mr. Big’s New Album, '…The Stories We Could Tell' (12/12/2014)
It’s been just over 25 years since virtuoso guitarist Paul Gilbert and bassist Billy Sheehan formed Mr. Big with singer Eric Martin and drummer Pat Torpey. At the time, Gilbert was just out of shred-metal act Racer X, and Sheehan was fresh off ...
Jim Dunlop Effect Pedal Throwdown, Round 1: Eric Johnson Fuzz Face Vs. Joe Bonamassa Fuzz Face (10/31/2014)
It's time to compare the mettle of Jim Dunlop pedals! In GuitarWorld.com's latest readers poll — the first annual Jim Dunlop Effect Pedal Throwdown — we're pitting Dunlop, MXR and Way Huge pedals against each other in a no-holds-barred shootout....
Betcha Can't Play This: Eric Johnson-Inspired Blues Shred in A Minor by Elliott Klein (10/28/2014)
It's time for another edition of Betcha Can't Play This! Welcome a new Betcha Can't Play This guitarist — Elliott Klein — and his first lick, a bit of Eric Johnson-inspired blues shred in A minor. As with the other new-for-2014 "Betcha Can't Pla...
Paul Gilbert: the 10 records that changed my life (10/27/2014)
Read more about Paul Gilbert: the 10 records that changed my life at MusicRadar.com Paul Gilbert is widely revered as being one of the globe's leading guitar virtuosos, his genre-bending versatility going hand-in-hand with the often frighteningl...
Eric Johnson and Mike Stern Discuss Their ‘Eclectic’ New Album (9/29/2014)
What do you get when you combine two bona-fide guitar heroes in their respective genres — and then have them go toe-to-toe with each other? You get Eclectic, a new album by blues/jazz/rocker Eric Johnson and jazz master Mike Stern. Recorded at ...
Watch Paul Gilbert Perform Van Halen's "Spanish Fly" (4/7/2014)
Below, check out a video of Racer X/Mr. Big guitarist Paul Gilbert playing "Spanish Fly," a classic 1979 instrumental tune by Van Halen. Although we're not sure when (or where) the brief clip was filmed, we do know it was posted to YouTube only ...
Video: Paul Gilbert Shreds on Electric Mandolin (3/11/2014)
And now, from the people who brought you "Video: Paul Gilbert Shreds on Stand-Up Bass," here's "Video: Paul Gilbert Shreds on Electric Mandolin"! The video — the latest clip to be posted on Gilbert's YouTube page — is a promo for Guitarfest in C...
Video: Paul Gilbert Shreds on Stand-Up Bass (2/18/2014)
Below, check out a new video that was posted to Paul Gilbert's official YouTube page. The clip shows Gilbert shredding on a stand-up bass — which probably shouldn't be called a stand-up bass in this instance since Gilbert is holding and playing...
NAMM 2014: Ibanez Guitars Introduces New Paul Gilbert Signature Model, the FRM250MF (1/24/2014)
Ibanez has introduced its new 25th-aniversay Paul Gilbert Fireman signature model, the FRM250MF. Gilbert posted the following on his Facebook page earlier today: "My new Ibanez signature model guitar has been announced! "I will be personally unv...
Preview Eric Johnson's New Single, "To Whom It May Concern" (1/16/2014)
In case you missed it over the holidays, guitarist Eric Johnson released a new single, "To Whom It May Concern," December 17 via Vortexan Music. Johnson has posted a 30-second clip of the song to his Soundcloud account, and you can check it out ...
Joe Satriani, Paul Gilbert, Andy Timmons and Mike Keneally Announce G4 Experience Guitar Camp (12/9/2013)
Joe Satriani, Paul Gilbert, Andy Timmons and Mike Keneally Announce G4 Experience Guitar Camp From August 11 to 15, 2014, musicians of all ages and levels will converge in California’s scenic Central Coast for the G4 Experience featuring Joe Sat...