Readers' Poll: Best Rock Headphone Song Ever — “Red Barchetta" (Rush) Vs. "Roundabout" (Yes)

by Guitar World Staff
Posted Nov 4, 2015 at 7:57am

What, exactly, is a headphone song? The definition changes depending on who you are.

For audiophiles, a headphone song—or album, for that matter—is a work that is so exquisite that it demands you listen to each beautifully recorded note under a sonic microscope. Miles Davis’ "Kind of Blue" fits that bill, the song and the album.

For others, a great "headphone work" is one that makes an intimate album more intimate (such as Bob Dylan’s original mono recordings), or a loud album louder (Rage Against the Machine’s debut effort).

We’re an unsubtle and hyperactive bunch here at Guitar World, so our favorite headphone songs seem to be those that have a lot of activity in the stereo field. As silly as it sounds, we love it every time a guitar solo takes a shortcut through our skulls as it zooms from one ear to the other.

Anyway, with the help of the gang at Blue Microphones, we've selected 16 of our favorite headphone songs—and we're asking you to vote for your favorites of the bunch! We've even launched a quick readers' poll—a bracket of 16 as opposed to our usual bracket of 32—so the tunes can shoot it out on GuitarWorld.com.

If you don’t know what we’re talking about—or you’ve never experienced any of the great songs listed in the bracket below—we suggest you go home, put on your best set of ‘phones, turn out the lights, turn up the volume and prepare to have your mind blown sky high. And vote, of course!

Note: All song titles used in this poll refer to the stereo studio versions, unless otherwise noted.

Enjoy our Best Rock Headphone Song Ever poll, which is sponsored by Blue Microphones!

Today's Matchup

“Red Barchetta" (Live), Rush

Taken from their standout 1980 Moving Pictures album, Rush’s “Red Barchetta” is a classic any way you slice it, but especially between the ears. Guitarist Alex Lifeson navigates seamlessly between the varying sections of the song, which was written about a sports car. What takes “Barchetta” over the top is the “wind in my hair” sequence at 2:34, where you’re instantly transported to the race track or, in this case, the riverside.




“Roundabout," Yes

Taken from their incredible fourth album, Fragile, Yes’ “Roundabout” is the band’s most recognizable track from their early prog-rock period. Through headphones, “Roundabout” is simply a party. Guitarist Steve Howe’s signature counterpoint licks and phrasing perfectly compliment the late Chris Squire’s thumping lead bass lines. Jon Anderson’s vocals add to the excitement of this eight-minute classic. If you’ve never listened to “Roundabout” through headphones, now would be a perfect time to check it out.



Vote Now!

Best Rock Headphone Song Ever: "Red Barchetta" (Live) (Rush) Vs. "Roundabout" (Yes)

Behold the Latest Bracket!

Dan

How the Bracket Was Compiled

hat.jpg

Here's how the bracket was—very unscientifically—compiled.

We drew the songs' names out of a hat (It was, in fact, a Quebec Nordiques baseball cap, which is called a casquette in Quebec) to help us create our bracket, which is available for your viewing pleasure below. Obviously, none of these songs are ranked or come from a previously compiled list, so we chose purely random matchups to have as little impact as possible on the final outcome.

Remember that, as with any poll, genre might occasionally clash against genre, so you'll just need to decide which song has (or has had) the most to offer within its genre.

As always, you can vote only once per matchup (once per device, that is), and we'll be posting match-ups pretty much every day of the month, sometimes more than once per day, just to give you an early warning. Merci!


Add a Comment
0 Comments

Similar Guitar News

Watch Rush Perform "Jacob's Ladder" for the First Time Since 1980 (5/12/2015)
Canadian prog-rock legends Rush recently began their 40th anniversary R40 Live Tour with a show at the BOK Center in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Though their set featured classics like "The Spirit of Radio" and "Tom Sawyer," it also featured notably obscu...
Rush's Alex Lifeson Discusses His History with PRS Guitars, R40 Tour and More — Video (7/30/2015)
Guitarist Alex Lifeson, one third of Canadian prog-rock legends Rush, recently sat down with the folks at PRS Guitars to discuss his history with the company and Rush's R40 tour in this exclusive video interview. You can check it out below. Th...
Pre-Teen Rockers Under The Radar Cover Rush and Black Sabbath — Video (5/18/2015)
Sure, in 2015—and on GuitarWorld.com—we've gotten used to videos of 8-year-olds shredding Racer X tunes and 14-year-olds who effortlessly knock out Yngwie solos. But there's still something fascinating about watching a band of pre-teens tackle—a...
Platinum Rush Video Blog #18 — Carolina Story (5/8/2015)
650 shows, 43 states, one baby and two hearts between'em. Meet Carolina Story. Like the friends you grew up with, Ben and Emily's songs are not trying to impress you but rather bring you closer to what who you've always been. Take a walk with...
Foo Fighters Perform Rush's "Tom Sawyer" with Yes Singer Jon Davison — Video (9/22/2015)
Here's a random one for ya. On September 19 in Anaheim, California, Foo Fighters brought Yes singer Jon Davison out on stage (who knew he was Foos drummer Taylor Hawkins' best friend?) to perform Rush's "Tom Sawyer." “He’s one of my best friends...
Platinum Rush Video Blog #17 – Scott Stevens (4/17/2015)
Scott Stevens seems to have everything it takes to make a sizable splash in the wide world of music. Command of the stage, strong vocals, authoritative guitar playing and a drive to make it all happen. But as much as that is, is it enough? Sc...
Acoustic RUSH — Top 10 Acoustic Rush Songs (3/17/2015)
If you’re a fan of Rush like I am, you probably know them for their hard-hitting, prog masterpieces like “Tom Sawyer,” “Spirit of Radio,” and “Limelight.” Decidedly electric and undeniably energetic, Rush’s intricate arrangements and complex rhy...
Platinum Rush Video Blog #15 — Andrew Tufano (3/13/2015)
Thinkin' bout coming to Nashville to make it in the big time? Here's a crash course in not "thinking" but "doing"! Meet Andrew Tufano. I saw him playing for a line of people waiting to get into Nashville's legendary Pancake Pantry early on a Su...
Platinum Rush Video Blog #14 — Maia Davies (3/1/2015)
I interviewed Maia Davies of Ladies Of The Canyon, an all-female band that are no strangers to hard livin', long drives and a life in music. Maia and I bonded on lessons learned on the road to success and more importantly perhaps, happiness. O...
Platinum Rush Video Blog #13 — Cody Brooks (2/11/2015)
When someone says "you have to see this guy" and that someone is Ken Coomer, former Wilco drummer and current hot producer in Nashville, you listen. Expecting a lot and hearing/seeing twice as much, though, is a whole different story. Meet Cody ...
John Petrucci and Rush's Geddy Lee Booked for 'That Metal Show' Season 14 Premiere (2/4/2015)
Rush’s Geddy Lee has been confirmed as a guest on this season's debut episode of That Metal Show. The show, which is hosted by Eddie Trunk, Don Jamieson and Jim Florentine, will air 9 p.m. EST and 11 p.m. EST February 21 on VH1 Classic. As a bon...
Platinum Rush Video Blog #12 — Bill Lloyd (1/28/2015)
Bill Lloyd doesn't play music, he IS music. And good music at that! From founding The Long Players, the uber popular band in Nashville who play classic albums from beginning to end with famous guest singers to in Nashville to writing his own c...
Alex Lifeson and Geddy Lee of Rush Choose 22 Songs That Inspired Them Most (9/28/2014)
In this interview from 2009, Rush’s guitarist — Alex Lifeson — and bassist — Geddy Lee — choose 60 minutes' worth of the music that is closest to their hearts, essentially putting together the ultimate Rush-approved "mixed tape." ALEX LIFESON: “...
John Petrucci of Dream Theater Discusses Rush's '2112' — The Record That Changed My Life (7/23/2014)
Dream Theater guitarist John Petrucci chooses (and discusses) the record that changed his life. Rush2112 (1976) “If I had to pick a favorite band of all time, it would be Rush. "As a teenager, I was already familiar with the group and its album...
New Book, 'Rush FAQ: All That's Left to Know About Rock's Greatest Power Trio,' Hits Stores This Month (6/10/2014)
Rush FAQ: All That’s Left to Know About Rock’s Greatest Power Trio by Max Mobley (June 2014, Backbeat Books, $24.99) documents the story of the Canadian prog-rock power trio’s journey from its origins in a church basement in Willowdale, Ontario,...